Hartz Heating & Cooling Inc.
  1. Home
  2. Guides
  3. Repair or replace checklist

Repair or replace? Run the four questions before anyone rings the bell.

The same guidance our technicians give on a service call, in the order they ask it, so you know where you stand before the dispatch fee.

Outside94°
Inside72°

The short answer

Replacement is on the table when an air conditioner is past ten years, a furnace past fifteen to twenty, or a furnace repair estimate reaches about $500. If the equipment is younger and the fix is small, repair it. Either way you get both numbers side by side before you choose.

10 yrsAC: replacement on the table
15–20furnace: efficiency fading
$500furnace repair estimate

1. How old is it?

The data plate on the outdoor unit or the furnace cabinet carries a manufacture date, sometimes hidden in the serial number. ENERGY STAR's guidance is to consider replacing a heat pump or air conditioner that is more than 10 years old, and newer systems are far more efficient; the energy bill often pays part of the difference. Furnaces run longer, but past fifteen to twenty years they lose efficiency quietly, and rising bills with no other explanation usually mean it is working harder to make the same heat.

2. What is the repair estimate?

On a system in its first years, almost any repair is worth doing. On an older furnace, a repair estimate of about $500 or more is the point where a new efficient model is usually the better investment, because you are paying to keep old parts running around the one that failed. Our report shows both figures side by side so the comparison is yours to make, not ours.

Technician writing up an estimate beside an air handler

3. What has the energy bill done?

Pull up twelve months of Duke Energy or Piedmont Natural Gas bills and compare each month with the same month a year earlier. A bill climbing with no change in the weather, the thermostat or the house is the system telling you it is losing ground. That is efficiency, not a breakdown, and it will not show up as a repair.

4. Is the house comfortable?

Warm and cold rooms, short cycling, a humid summer, water at the air handler. Some of these are the system's age and some are sizing or airflow, which a new unit the same size would not cure. A load calculation tells the truth, and it is part of a free estimate on a new system.

What happens when you call

A repair visit carries a modest dispatch fee and gets you a complete diagnostic; the technician talks you through repair now, repair later or replace, with the price of each. If the answer is a new system, the estimate is free, the proposal is emailed and mailed, and every replacement is permitted and inspected by your county. Financing is available once you have accepted the proposal: GoodLeap, Duke Energy or Piedmont Natural Gas (for their customers, on the utility bill), OneMain Financial in Concord, or Payzer online.

Not sure which one you have?

Weekdays we run a full schedule; weekends we answer for emergencies. (704) 455-1566

Questions, then the request

Questions this guide raises.

The things people ask on the phone, answered the same way here. Anything else, the office answers weekdays; weekends are for emergencies, and we answer those too.

Weekdays, and weekends for emergencies(704) 455-1566

Request service

Tell us what the system is doing.

Weekend emergency? Do not wait on the form: call (704) 455-1566.

Is the estimate free?

For a new system, yes. For a repair there is a modest dispatch fee, which covers a complete diagnostic. The technician tells you what is wrong and what the repair costs before doing anything; a major component such as a compressor or coil is quoted in a written proposal.

Do I have to decide on the spot?

No. The report is yours to keep, the proposal for a replacement is emailed and mailed, and nothing happens until you say so.

Can I finance a repair?

Our financing partners are for system replacement, after you accept the written proposal. We do not finance in-house.

Call nowRequest service